12 May 2009 company   » (Master)


It’s early in the morning, I get up. During breakfast I check the happenings on the web on my desktop - my laptop broke again. People blog about the new Gnumeric release that just hit the repositories. I click the link and it starts. I play around in it until I need to leave.
On the commute I continue surfing the web on my mobile. I like the “resume other session” feature. Turns out there’s some really cute features in the new Gnumeric that I really need to try.
Fast forward, I’m at the university. Still some time left before the meeting, so I can play. I head to the computer facilities in the lab, log in and start Gnumeric. Of course it starts up just as I left it at home: same settings, same version, same document.
20 minutes later, I’m in the meeting. As my laptop is broken, I need to use a different computer for my slides. I grab a random one and do the usual net login. It looks just like at home. 3 clicks, and the right slides are up.

This is my vision of how I will be using my computer in the future. (The previous paragraph sounds awkward, but describing ordinary things always does, doesn’t it?) So what are the key ingredients here?

The key ingredient is ubiquity. My stuff is everywhere. It’s of course on my desktop computer and my laptop. But it’s also on every other computer in the world, including Bill Gates’ cellphone. I just need to log in. It will run on at least as many devices as current web apps like GMail does today. And not only does GMail run everywhere, but my GMail runs everywhere: It has all my emails and settings available all the time. I want a desktop that is as present as GMail.

So here’s a list of things that need to change in GNOME to give it ubiquity:

  • I need my settings everywhere

    Currently it is a hard thing to make sure one computer has the same panel layout as another one. I bet at least 90% of the people configure their panels manually and download their background image again when they do a new install. So roughly every 6 months. Most people don’t even know that copying the home directory from the old setup solves these issues. But I want more than that. Copying the home directory is a one-time operation but stuff should be continually synchronized. In GNOME, we could solve most of this already by making gconf mirror the settings to a web location, say gconf.gnome.org and sync whenever we are connected.

  • I need my applications everywhere

    I guess you know what a pain it is when you’ve set up a new computer and all the packages are missing. Gnumeric isn’t installed, half the files miss thumbnailers, bash tells you it doesn’t know all those often-used commands and no configure script finds all pkg-config files. Why doesn’t the computer just install the files when it needs them? Heck, you could probably implement it right now by mounting /usr with NFS from a server that has all packages installed. Say x86.jaunty.ubuntu.com? Add a huge 15GB offline cache on my hard disk using some sort of unionfs. Instantly all the apps are installed and run without me manually installing them. As a bonus, you get rid of nagging security update dialogs.

  • I really need my applications everywhere

    Have you ever noticed that all our GNOME applications only work on a desktop computer? GNOME Mobile has been busy duplicating all our applications for mobile devices: different browser, different file manager, different music player. And of course those mobile applications use other methods to store settings. So even if the settings were synced perfectly, it wouldn’t help against having to configure again. Instead of duplicating the applications, could we please just adapt the user interfaces?

When looking at this list, and comparing it to the web, it’s obvious to me why people prefer the web as an application delivery platform, even though the GNOME APIs are way nicer. The web gets all of those points right:

  • My settings are stored on some server, so they are always available.
  • Applications are installed on demand - without even asking the users. The concept is called “opening a web page”.
  • Device ubiquity is the only thing the web doesn’t get perfect by default. But a) the browser developers are hard at work ensuring that every web site works fine on all devices, no matter the input method or the screen size and b) complex sites can and do ship user interfaces adapted to different devices.

The web has its issues, too - like offline availability and performance - but it gets these steps very right.

So how do we get there? I don’t think it’s an important question. It’s not even an interesting question to me. The question that is interesting to me is: Do we as GNOME want to go there? Or do we keep trying to work on our single-user oriented desktop platform?

Syndicated 2009-05-12 18:47:11 from Swfblag

Latest blog entries     Older blog entries

New Advogato Features

New HTML Parser: The long-awaited libxml2 based HTML parser code is live. It needs further work but already handles most markup better than the original parser.

Keep up with the latest Advogato features by reading the Advogato status blog.

If you're a C programmer with some spare time, take a look at the mod_virgule project page and help us with one of the tasks on the ToDo list!